Secure Cloud as CodeThe weakest link in security is not the technology.
By Jonathan Armas | May 02, 2019
Amazon Web Services (AWS) is one of the biggest cloud services
used by thousands of companies around the world,
and with a centralized and strong security,
it is one of the best on the market.
Services like Terraform or
allow us to write our infrastructure definitions as code
in an easy and maintainable way,
being capable of storing it on a repository,
deploying it using
Continuous Integration (
and changing the infrastructure on the fly
with minimal to no availability issues.
Securing this new way of infrastructure is a must.
As a pentester, I have seen many vulnerabilities
in how the code is written, stored and deployed,
which are also mistakes that we should avoid
in order to present the most robust infrastructure.
Here we are going to discuss some of the most critical and recurrent holes
AWS Infrastructure as Code (
Let’s talk about credentials.
AWS provides a powerful way of storing and managing credentials
Identity and Access Management (IAM).
Here we can create users and assign roles, permissions and secret keys,
one of the most important things when we talk about
These are a set of key pairs consisting of an
AccesKey and a
that allow us to connect to the service using the
the provider of
IaC cli or our own
We all know that we should protect our credentials;
this is the first thing that appears when we talk about confidentiality but,
are you truly protecting your credentials on your
The answer is no.
The most common faults that we find when we test
are clear text secrets and hard-coded credentials.
Even though your code is “secure”
in a password protected repository,
there is no need to store
AWS keys on it;
anyone with access to the code can view and consume your keys,
causing loss of confidentiality, integrity and availability
of the data and services that you want to protect.
Even if you encrypt your keys,
you must not store them in your code.
I have seen keys with a
base64 encoding that anyone can view anyway,
keys encrypted with old algorithms that a pentester can bruteforce
and keys encrypted with a secure algorithm (like
with the decryption key hard-coded in clear text or encoded with
So, what is the solution to this problem?
Use environment variables.
An environment variable is an easy and secure way of storing your credentials. You can control who has access to these keys and change them without touching your code, but you need to be sure to delete them from your repository history or change them when you migrate to environment variables (We can find them with tools like Trufflehog). Services like Gitlab CI have this method, or you can use a service for credential storage like AWS Secrets Manager or Hashicorp Vault to securely store your keys and passwords, access them whenever you need and have a clear principle of roles and least privilege, so important when you want to maintain confidentiality. And, talking about roles, are you setting them correctly? Again, nope.
As I said,
AWS has a module named
where we can set users, roles and access keys to the
Most of the times I have compromised
they were configured with excessive permissions.
Keys that should only have access
Amazon Simple Storage Service (Amazon S3)
also have access to the
AWS Secrets Manager,
Amazon Elastic Compute Cloud (EC2) and so on.
An attacker (
80% of the time an employee) that obtains credentials
as we saw on the last point
could access almost all of the organization cloud infrastructure,
extracting more secrets,
reading and/or modifying
S3 web pages and files,
shutting down servers, among others.
Having the principle of least privilege on your cloud is a must,
you need to set users only for the tasks that this user is meant to do,
and configuring its roles and policies correctly.
Finally, the third and one of the most underestimated vulnerability
that I have encountered is logical access.
This means access to a server through an
access to an
Amazon Relational Database Service (RDS)
through the port
or having the administration server open to the world using port
An open port is a window to your infrastructure
increasing the attack surface
that we as pentesters can exploit,
so why open it to the world?
Most of the time
IaC developers set the network access to the services
because “all” of the services should have access,
but if an attacker has access to a set of credentials
for the database,
SSH or administration service
either by brute-forcing it or reading it in clear text
(we talked about this a lot),
he can wreak havoc in your systems.
You need to set the network permissions
using the principle of least privilege too.
Only the core servers should have access to the database,
only the administration network segment
should have access to the administration services and so on.
This can be done by writing restrictive network rules in your code,
setting them to the specific
IPs that need to have access to your services,
and using environment variables
in order to prevent in-office attacks
when an employee changes this settings in the code.
In conclusion, the cloud is dominating the world
IaC is at the moment the best way
of having your organization core accessible
and maintainable, but it comes with certain risks.
You should protect your credentials at all costs,
using environmental variables or vault services
that securely store your keys.
Also, have a good policy of least privilege for your users and roles
when accessing your cloud services
as well as for the network access of your servers and databases.
With this measures you can build
the most robust, scalable and maintainable infrastructure
for your company and you can ensure
that it is safe against these attacks.